A Common Tale: Understanding Responsive Desire

Have you ever found yourself thinking, “Wow, that was great—why don’t I do that more often?” after sex… only to roll your eyes at the idea the next time it crosses your mind?

If so, you’re not alone.

Many people reflect on their earlier years – perhaps in their teens or twenties – and wonder what happened to that constant excitement. Maybe you used to feel perpetually ‘in the mood’, or maybe that has never quite been your experience. Either way, the idea that sexual desire is just always there can feel like a myth – especially when life gets more complicated.

Challenging the Old Models

We’ve been taught to think of sexual desire as a state of being: you either have it or you don’t. Even early models of sexual response, like the one proposed by the founding fathers of Sexology, Masters and Johnson, framed desire as the very first step (they called it excitement, followed by plateau, orgasm, resolution)

But for many people, that model doesn’t quite fit.

In reality, desire isn’t always the starting line. Sometimes we need to walk some of the track before we get the urge to run. This is where responsive desire comes in.

What Is Responsive Desire?

Responsive desire means a person may not initially feel ‘in the mood’ but chooses (consensually!) to engage in sexual activity anyway – often because they’re open to connection, intimacy, or curiosity. Once things begin, arousal and desire start to emerge…

This process is sometimes referred to as the arousability of the sexual system. Essentially, once you start to experience physical or emotional arousal, your brain and body begin to respond. This can lead to increased sensitivity, faster orgasm, or stronger connection. It’s not forced or fake – it’s just a different pathway.

Hormones and Conditioning

Testosterone plays a role in sexual desire, and those with higher levels often experience more frequent spontaneous desire – the kind that comes out of nowhere and feels urgent. People with penises often experience erections alongside this, and over time, that pairing can become ingrained: erection = desire. (Literally Pavlov dogging there way to arousal). 

But that’s not always the case. Erections can happen without interest in sex – just as desire can exist without any immediate physical signs.

For people with vulvas, the picture is often less straightforward. Physical arousal can be harder to detect, and studies show that objective arousal (what’s happening in the body) doesn’t always align with subjective arousal (how turned on someone feels). This helps explain why responsive desire is often more common in people with vulvas.

So, What Can You Do?

Some people find that the more they engage in enjoyable sex, the more they desire it. But that’s not a universal rule, and that’s okay.

A helpful tip? Aim for at least 80% of your sexual experiences to feel positive or pleasurable. Not every sexual moment will be mind-blowing (just like not every slice of cake is the best you’ve ever had), but good enough is often reason enough to try again another day.

If you or your partner are feeling confused or disconnected about your desire, you’re not broken. You may simply be experiencing a different – but very normal – way of engaging with your sexuality.

Curious to explore this more? Our therapists are here to help you unpack what desire looks like for you – without shame, pressure, or judgment.